Elias Roberts Mexican War Pension — Page 22

Survivor's Brief — 1893 Increase Rejected

This is the formal Survivor's Brief evaluating Elias Roberts' 1893 increase claim, with attorney Henry D. Phillips listed as recognized attorney. Examiner D. W. Harper submitted the claim for rejection on July 25, 1893, and Legal Reviewer H. W. Hall approved the rejection on July 28 — not on destitution grounds (the printed template clause about insufficient means is struck through), but on the same service-eligibility ground raised on page 21: that Roberts had not served 60 days in Mexico, on the coast or frontier, or en route, and so was "not a survivor" under the 1887 act. The brief recalculates his credited service at 41 days, and the declaration itself was formally rejected on that basis.

Full Transcription

INCREASE. (top, printed, with a handwritten "Ctf. No. 17403" beside it)

O. MEXICAN WAR PENSION.

Acts of January 29, 1887, and January 5, 1893.

SURVIVOR'S BRIEF.

Claimant, Elias Roberts

P. O., Hockley . . . Rank, Private

County, Harris . . . Company, Gillespie's

State, Tex . . . Regiment, Hay[s'] Texas Mtd Vol.

Rate, $12 per month, commencing .................

RECOGNIZED ATTORNEY.

Name, Henry D. Phillips . . . Fee, $ .............; Agent to pay.

P. O., City . . . Articles filed .............., 189 .

APPROVALS.

Approved for Rejection

Submitted July 25, 1893; D. W. Harper, Examiner.

Approved for [Rejection?] Claimant [is] in such destitute circumstances that eight dollars per month are insufficient to provide him the necessaries of life — Claimant did not [serve] 60 days in Mexico or on [the] coast, or en route thereto, or actually engage[d] in battle — [not?] a survivor under Act Jan'y 29 '87 [?]

H. W. Hall, Legal Reviewer.

July 28, 1893 . . . ................., Re-Reviewer.

Approved for .................

Claimant is ................. wholly disabled for manual labor (right/medical column left otherwise blank — no Med. Ex'r, Med. Reviewer, or Med. Referee entries)

DATES OF SERVICE.

Enlisted . . . April 24 . . . , 1847 . . . Subsequent or prior service, .................

Discharged . . . June 4 . . . , 1847

Length of service: 41 days.

Pensioned at $8 per month from Jan 29, 1887

Issued Feb. 7, 1890, under act January 29, 1887.

Pensioned under former laws, by Certificate No. ................., from ................., 18 , to ................., 18 , and last paid at $ ......... per month.

PRESENT CLAIM.

Act January 5, 1893.

Declaration filed April 18, 1893,

Rejected on the ground that the soldier was not in Mexico on the coast or frontier thereof or en route thereto 60 days

(further handwritten line, only partly legible, bottom edge of scan:) Writes [?] brief for dropping.

(printed form number, bottom left:) 6–844

Scanned image of the July 1893 Survivor's Brief rejecting Elias Roberts' pension increase claim.
Page 22 — elias-roberts-mexican-war-pension-page-022.tif (click image to view full-resolution scan)